It's Only Fair Pt. 01

"That's a good girl. He'll be up in no time."

I looked over to source of the sound and saw Amy standing in the doorway. Light from the hallway washed over her. My older sister was back in her blue tank top and grey sweatpants. I started to ask what was going on, then suddenly I felt a small, warm hand wrap around my dick.

I'd fallen asleep naked, I remembered, but alone. Now there was definitely someone in the bed with me. I pulled the covers aside and looked down, my eyes adjusting to the darkness. To my shock, Jenna was there kneeling over me, my dick in her hand. She gave me a silly grin and leaned down.

"Oh fuck!" The words shot out of me as Jenna wrapped her warm lips around my dong. Her long brown hair tickled at my thighs. She licked up and down slowly. Like getting a feel for it. My sister was clearly struggling with what she was doing. But her enthusiasm made up for any inexperience.

"I was asleep when Jenna came and woke me. Our little sister was still feeling worked up from before," Amy said casually, "I didn't think it was such a good idea, but..."

I heard Jenna try to say something, but her mouth was too full of dick for me to understand.

"Jenna insisted," Amy said, "I can't say no to my little sister. I hope you don't mind indulging her."

All I could do was shake my head. My sister's sucking was getting tighter. She still had her hand on me as well. God it felt so good.

"Do you think he's ready to go?" Amy asked.

"Definitely," Jenna said, pulling off my penis with a pop. She kept idly stroking my dick with her hand. I was so hard, it ached. You'd think I'd never cum in my life with how bad I was wanting it. I bucked my hips, like Brianna had before, trying to get my dick back in my sister's moist mouth.

"OK, well hop to it," Amy said, "I want to get back to bed." My big sister didn't act like she was in a hurry, however. She leaned against the doorway and stared intently at the two of us.

Jenna was in her undershirt and boy shorts from before, but that was it. Now she shucked off her panties and tossed them to the side. She took my dick and pointed it downward. My little sister lay herself over me and ground her pubis down on mine. We both groaned as our bare parts made contact. Automatically, my hands shot up and gripped Jenna's hips. Her little legs felt so thin. The brunette wiggled her nearly non-existent backside, pressing onto me more. Not even inside my sister, I could feel the heat of her sex over mine.

"In her, not on her," Amy said, "Jeez you two really are hopeless."

"I'm trying to get... He might be ready but I'm not," Jenna said.

Amy walked into the bedroom. Even in the dark, her green eyes seemed to shine.

"First off," she said, "Being on top is, like, the worst way to lose your virginity ever. Trust me, you can't do anything." The blonde girl gently grabbed her sister's shoulder and pushed her off. Jenna sprawled onto the bed next to me.

Freed from my Jenna's dry humping, my penis popped up and bobbed excitedly. Amy stared down and seemed to lose her train of thought for a moment, but she quickly recovered.

"The best way to be pierced by a penis for the first time is to let him do it. That way you can tell him what you like or whatever," Amy said, "Let me help set you two up."

Amy reached down and pulled off Jenna's undershirt, causing the brunette's little tits to bounce free. Her little boobs, capped with puffy, pink nubbins, looked oh-so-suckable. "It's not sex unless you're naked," Amy explained. She carefully moved Jenna around, like posing a doll, till my little sister was on all fours. Her pert little butt pointing in the air.

"Sweetie are you sure you've been through puberty?" Amy asked, "No hips, no tits, not even pubes."

"I shaved them," Jenna said. Her face even pinker than usual. "I thought it made my pussy look weird."

"I think it's really hot, sis," I told Jenna. She blushed.

"Whatever," Amy said, rolling her eyes. Then she pulled me to the back of the bed so that I was right behind my sister. My cock pointed straight at Jenna's exposed pink opening. Amy grabbed my cock and rubbed it up and down my little sister's slit.

"Now put that in there," Amy said, "Same rules as before though, understand? A few pumps to give your sister the feel of it. None of the, you know, the other stuff from last time. I expect you to stay in control."

"OK," Jenna and I chorused.

"You think you're ready, sis?" I asked.

"God yes," Amy said, "Get it over with so I can get to sleep."

"I meant Jenna. She said before she was..."

"It'll be fine," Amy said, "Stick it in and she'll adjust. Trust me."

I looked over at Jenna. She was already biting her bottom lip. Bracing for it.

"I don't want to hurt my sister," I said.

Amy sighed dramatically. "Fine. She licked you. Why don't you return the favor?"

I squatted down and lined my mouth up with my sister's bare, pink pussy. I swear I even saw a droplet drip down. Wow. My little sister had a super sexy snatch. I mean, it's hard not to have one. But Jenna's seemed even more fuckable than the usual. If that makes sense? Whatever. In the moment it made sense.

Tentatively, I put my tongue on my little sister's bare puss. It was only a light touch, but I felt Jenna shiver and stretch as my tongue made contact. I started lapping harder. Jenna tasted pretty good - sweet, salty, and strong - and I focused on making her body respond to my mouth.

I felt a finger brush across my face and looked up. Amy had taken it upon herself to help things along and now she was rubbing at our younger sister's clit. The brunette's whole body jerked as Amy made contact.

"That doing it for you, Jen?" Amy asked.

"Uh huh," Jenna said. Her voice strained.

"Lick faster if you can," Amy said, then to our sister, "Let me know when you're getting close."

"Uh huh," Jenna said.

"Slip a finger into her pussy," Amy said. I did as I was told. I felt my little sister's tight channel squeeze down on my digit. I pushed as deep as I could, then pulled back. Like a little penis. Then I remembered something I'd read online. I twisted my hand, so my finger pointed upward and curled it into a C-shape. I felt a patch of flesh that was raised. Spongy. Slowly I dragged my finger over that spot.

"AH!" I felt Jenna stiffen above me. "Gonna..."

Amy grabbed me by the cock and pulled. My finger slipped out of my sister. I dropped my head from her cunt.

Jenna dropped to the bed. She was panting. Looking back at both me and Amy with real anger in her face.

"I told you to tell me before you came," Amy said.

"I... didn't... Fuck. So close," Jenna growled.

"Good, now you're ready for your big brother's dick," Amy said. She went around and helped Jenna back up to her knees. Then she gestured for me to stand behind my baby sister.

Once again, I aimed my cock at my little sister's bare pussy. Her labia was practically purple and gaping open. Even in the dark, I could see my sister's juices glistening on her skinny thighs.

I started to rock forward. My cockhead kissed my sister's opening. Amy grabbed the shaft and held me back.

"What's Chase doing?" Amy asked Jenna.

"Putting it in me," Jenna said. Amy still wouldn't let me move. "My brother. He's putting his penis inside me."

"Do you want it?" Amy asked.

"So bad," Jenna said, then quickly corrected herself, "I want my brother's big dick in me so bad, Amy. Please."

"That's my girl," Amy said. She started dragging my forward. Feeding my cock into our little sister.

Brianna, Jenna's twin, her pussy had felt like nothing I'd ever experienced. I'd thought Jenna's would be similar, but I was wrong. My sister's twat was tight. At the most cock-gripping that Brianna's slot had been, at her climax, Jenna's own quim started there.

Then Jenna flexed her sex and it was somehow even tighter.

"Holy fuck, sis." I couldn't help it. My penis was in my little sister's pussy. Oh God.

Jenna didn't say anything. I saw she was biting her lip again. Eyes wide. Her cute pink face racked with pleasure or pain I couldn't tell. Probably both.

I pulled back a bit. As soon as it was just the head, however, my older sister shoved me forward again. Amy's fist soon ran out of room and she let go. And I slid into my younger sister all the way to the bottom.

I looked down and clearly saw where my cock met Jenna's pussy. My balls so close to her, they could have been attached to her body instead of mine. Her little brown star winked up at me from between her little pink buttcheeks. I resisted the urge jam my thumb in there, as well.

Jenna took a deep breath. Her cunt rippled over my cock. I slid my hands down to cup Jenna's tits. Her nipples felt practically sharp on my palms. It wasn't a comfortable position, draped over her like that, but I didn't care.

Jenna strained back at me, reminding me I had more important duties. I straightened and rested my hands on my little sister's tiny bottom.

"Remember the rules," Amy said.

I looked over at her quizzically. Amy was sitting on the bed, off to the side. Still fully clothed. She arched her eyebrow at me.

"Five pumps," Amy said, "Give her the feel of it, but that's all. That way it's... innocent. Not, ummm."

"Incest?" Jenna asked, her voice cracked.

"Right," Amy said, "It's just siblings learning together, you know? Nothing wrong with that."

I drew back slow, same as I'd done with Brianna. As I slid back in, Jenna started breathing hard out of her nose, like a bull getting ready to charge.

"Harder," Jenna said. She had her head bowed straight down.

"You sure?" I asked. Jenna reached back and pinched my thigh. Well OK then. I pulled back quick and stabbed into my little sister. Our hips met with a loud SNAP!

"Faster," Jenna said.

Well I'd learned my lesson from last time. I stopped slowly pumping my little sister and started, for real now, to fuck her. Any thought of limits blew past me as I hammered little Jenna's grasping cunt. Her pussy tried so hard to hold on - every time I went in was like taking her virginity all over again. It was work, but effort like this was too incredible for me to care.

I looked over at Amy, I guess expecting her to intervene. Instead she just nodded at me slightly. The room filled with the squeaks of the bed. The smacks of our bodies. Jenna's little "Uhn uhn uhns" punctuated every push.

I glorified in my little sister's body as I fucked her. Her little anus opening and closing slightly. Her hips rocking back and forth with my thrusts. Her tiny tits hanging down, conical. Her face practically cherry red. Green eyes aglow in the darkness.

Jenna's pussy rippled right up my shaft and I felt my orgasm close in on me. I'd never been so disappointed to cum - I wanted to keep fucking my sexy little sister forever. Still, I knew from last time not to risk it. I slowed and started to pull out.

Jenna was still groaning, "Oh oh oh... no no No NO! What are you doing?"

"I was getting close," I said, "I didn't want to...

"Fuck! Don't stop now," Jenna said. I noticed she was panting hard. Her whole body seemed to cinch as she rocked back and forth, trying to force me to keep pounding her.

"But what if I...?"

"It's fine," Amy said, "I'm already getting one pill. Won't hurt to pick up a second."

"Are you sure?" I asked.

"Yes!" both girls shouted at the same time.

I drove forward with abandon. My balls bounced off my sister's clit as we slammed into each other.

"Oh yes..." Jenna said. Knowing that I was going to go all the way with her seemed to kick her into overdrive. "Oh God. Fuck. Fuck ME."

"Amazing right?" Amy said.

"So good," Jenna said.

"What's he doing to you?" Amy said, "Tell me."

"Fuh... Fuck. My brother is fucking me so... SO goooood," Jenna said. She threw her head up and stiffened. "Ohhhhhhhhhh OH!"

Her pussy wrapped around me, even impossibly tighter, but I managed not to cum. I'd done it. I'd given my sister an orgasm. I figured she'd let me stop. But as soon as Jenna came down from her high, the brunette teen immediately began ramming herself onto my cock all over again.

Jenna's explosion hastened mine along. I started grunting with every push.

"He's going to do it," Amy said, "Your brother's going to cum in you."

"Oh please," Jenna said, "Oh big brother give me all of it. I need it so bad."

"Your brother's going to fill your unprotected pussy," Amy said.

"Please," Jenna said, "Please cum in meeeeeeee."

My body stilled. My little sister's pussy squeezed down on me and the only thing I could do was let loose.

"Oh FUCK! Fuck fucking YES!" Jenna screamed.

Amy reached back and grabbed my balls, nesting them in her palm as they emptied into our little sister. Like coaxing even more sperm to come out.

"Give it to her, Chase. Fill our little sister up."

I stayed buried in my sister. My sperm gushed right into her welcoming womb. Every time I thought I had no more to give, I squirted out another stream of my seed. I fell forward onto Jenna and held her tight. Both of us trembling. My pleasure was more than I could handle. I couldn't even keep my eyes open. Just held onto my sister like a rock in the flood as I flooded her with my fertility. So much that I felt the warmth of it start leaking out over my balls.

Finally, Jenna fell forward. My cock drooled out a little more, but it was already softening. Jenna buried her head in my pillows. She made a sound like sobbing. I fell down next to her. Reached over and pushed her brown hair out of her eyes. I saw my sister was laughing. She smiled and then we both caught the giggles. I tried to speak, but more laughter spilled out.

"That was really good," Jenna said. Still at a loss for words, I kissed my sister's pink cheeks. Her forehead. She stroked my hair and kissed me on the cheek.

"Thanks big bro," Jenna whispered and rolled out of the bed. My sister didn't even bother with her underwear, she just started to stumble out the doorway.

"Finally," Amy said, "Took you two long enough." She followed Jenna out of my room. But right before she closed the door, Amy looked back at me and gave me a thumbs up.

The room went dark. I lay back on the bed, blown. Yet something itched in my mind. Kept the sleep from surrounding me.

Amy kept encouraging me to fuck our younger sisters and I couldn't understand why. If she found me attractive, why didn't she just take me for herself? Even if she didn't, why did she seem so invested in me being with Jenna and Brianna?

And what about the twins, themselves? Were they doing this to, in some weird way, please their older sister? Or did they have their own mysterious motivations?

It was all so puzzling. But before I could start putting things together, I'd already drifted off to sleep.

*

I woke up the next morning in my bed, alone. Lost somewhere between relieved and disappointed. The sunlight streamed over bright into my room. I rolled out of bed and looked out the window. We'd gotten a foot of snow overnight. Maybe more. My parents hadn't made up the whole blizzard thing, after all.

I stood up and got dressed - just a t-shirt and a pair of plaid pj pants. It felt like a lazy morning and I couldn't see putting on real clothes. Then I made my way downstairs.

"Well, I'm not going out in this, that's for sure," I heard Amy say, "I can't believe they haven't even plowed the roads yet." The girls were all sitting around the dining room table drinking coffee. They were still in their outfits from the day before - Amy in her tank top and sweats, the twins in their panties and undershirts.

"This whole area is kind of secluded," Jenna said, "The plows probably won't get here till the afternoon."

As I walked into the dining room, I eyed the girls suspiciously. Especially the twins. After I'd filled them up the day before, I figured I was about to get an earful back.

Instead all three women smiled at me, even Amy, as I came into the kitchen. Brianna popped out of her chair and gave me a big hug and a kiss on the cheek. Her giant rack pressed into my shoulder.

"I'll go get you some coffee, big man," she said, tousling my hair. She sauntered into the kitchen, swaying her ample hips.

I sat down at the table, and Jenna reached over and squeezed my hand.

"Stop looking at us like we're going to explode," Jenna said, "We're fine."

"Seriously," Amy said, "You put your sperm in them, not nitro-glycerin." Her comment didn't make me feel any better. I grimaced in reply.

Brianna came back with a steaming mug of coffee and slid it in front of me. Then she sat on the other side of the table with her two sisters. The room, like the rest of the house, was bright and airy. A little post-snow cold.

"Mom and Dad texted while you were sleeping," Brianna said, "They got it even worse up where they are. We probably won't see them till tonight."

"We'll have a nice lazy day at home," Amy said. The girls all looked at me with less than wholesome smiles. But Amy quickly waved her finger at them both. "Last night was special but it was a one-time thing. I'm still in charge, so don't go getting any ideas, Inseminator." She pointed at me, accusingly.

I nearly spit out my coffee. What did she just call me?

"I am the Inseminator," Jenna said in her best Ah-nold voice, "Cum in me if you want to live."

"Get to the pussy!" Brianna said, doing the same imitation. The twins practically fell out of their chairs laughing. Well, I supposed if they could feel OK with it, I could too.

"Seriously, Chase, it's OK," Jenna said once she got control of herself. Her face so bright it looked like she'd had another orgasm.

"You didn't do anything to us that we didn't want," Brianna said, "Besides, Amy will take care of it as soon as the roads clear, right?"

"You bet," Amy said. But she was staring off into the distance as she said it. Like her mind was somewhere else entirely.

*

The twins made breakfast, eggs and bacon, and we all ate together. This was nice. Familial. In a way that I hadn't felt in a long time with my three sisters. Maybe ever. We were all so different and distant. Who'd have thought that the way to fix our family was to fuck it up?

After we were finished eating, Jenna and Brianna agreed to clean up while I went upstairs to shower and get dressed.

"You sure I can't do anything?" I asked, but the twins shooed me away.

I couldn't understand how sex could leave me feeling so sore. It was supposed to be pleasurable, it was pleasurable, yet it left me hurting like I'd been roughed into the boards all night. I felt stiff, crusty. Clumsy and out of focus. I thought about jumping into my parents' hot tub, but I decided to take a shower in my own bathroom instead. It felt more comfortable to me to be in my own space.

I stood under the steaming water for a long time, my mind oddly empty. I didn't want to think about what had happened the night before. Couldn't stop thinking about it. I wanted to run downstairs and hug my sisters, tell them I was sorry, and beg them to forget it had ever happened. I wanted to run downstairs and bend Brianna over on the couch. Plug her pussy while I lapped at her twin sister's sex. Then switch out and do it all over again with the other girl. And Amy. My God, Amy. Is it wrong to admit, having had both twins, I still ached for my older sister?

Amazingly, though not surprising considering, I stepped out of the shower with a massive hard-on. Well it was too late to do anything about it by then. Besides, I was so worn out from the day before, I felt like I'd be rubbing myself for hours before I could reach relief.

I wrapped a towel around my waist. Shaved. Then I walked across the hall to my bedroom. I swung open the door. I couldn't believe what was waiting for me there.