My Sister Made Me Ch. 05

"Do you like that?" Pastor Dan asked her.

She couldn't help herself, and nodded. His cock pulled free and she gasped out loud. Whoever was behind her wasn't stopping. She knew now that someone was using their tongue on her, and oh my, did it feel good! She knew that she should stop it, but she couldn't. All those months of being sexually frustrated had weakened her resolve to a point that she simply couldn't bear to stop what was happening.

The sensation of the warm wet tongue on her privates was incredible. Whoever was doing it was very good at what they were doing. Of course she had no basis to compare and was only guessing.

"What... what... is...," she stammered. "Oh... oh my..."

A female voice broke the moans. "You told me she was horny, but I thought we'd get more resistance than this."

Sam's mind was whirling. "A woman..." she muttered. "Oh... my... yes... no..."

Pastor Dan pushed his cock into her mouth again and she hungrily sucked it in. Part of her was still saying, "Go for it," and the other was now saying, "You can be mad later."

The female that had spoken behind her was back at running her tongue up and down Sam's softer parts. The sensation was incredible, and she couldn't help but start to feel lightheaded and tingly.

Pastor Dan was groaning somewhere above her, his cock still sliding in and out of her mouth. She'd totally forgotten about him and had been enjoying the feeling of the woman's warm tongue on her most intimates. A final cry of excitement from him, and his cock burst forth its load onto her tongue. That brought her back to the present and the immediate pleasure she felt as he coated her mouth. She swallowed obediently, relishing the gooey texture and odd taste that she enjoyed so much as it slid down her throat. He continued to fill her mouth as two hands pushed against her buttocks. She felt the warm tongue sliding up and down her womanhood push gently into her and then onto a particular spot that really, really felt good. Lips pressed against the spot and she could feel more of the woman's face.

"Oh... oh...," Samantha stammered again and again. Cum was dribbling down her face, so she swallowed quickly. Dan had finished cumming, and she didn't feel him anymore. Then, something indescribable happened to her. She felt a sensation, almost like a wave, wash over her. She'd never felt such pleasure in her life and knew that she didn't want it to stop, no matter how much of a sin it was. Her nether regions tightened up and she groaned, her eyes rolling back under the blindfold and her mouth hanging open.

"She's cumming," Pastor Dan said.

"Mmmhmm," the female voice agreed behind her.

"That was faster than I had figured," he added.

The warm tongue retreated from her nether regions as she came down off of the mountain of pleasure and suddenly reality began to set in. Someone had just kissed and licked her most intimate parts!

"Pastor Dan, what's going on?" she asked, breathing heavily, her mouth still sticky with cum.

"Samantha," he said, pulling her blindfold off. "You know my wife."

Confused, Sam let her eyes adjust and then looked around, wondering what he'd gotten her in to. Sure enough, his wife, Amanda was smiling sweetly at her. She walked around on her knees to Sam's front, still strapped down as she was.

"Pastor Dan?" Sam asked, tears coming to her eyes. "I don't understand!"

He smiled and looked down. "I know you don't. I just don't want to keep secrets from you anymore."

"You're the one that's been sucking my husband's cock?" Amanda, asked.

"I... I...," she stammered, tears flowing.

"No, no!" Amanda said, moving quickly. She leaned in and kissed Sam's tear stained cheek. "No, angel," she said again and again. "No more tears, you're not in trouble."

She brushed Sam's hair from her face and kissed her forehead.

"Can you unstrap me?" Sam asked, looking over her shoulder, still crying. "I can explain everything!" she said, still more than a little freaked out.

"We will sugar," Dan said. "We need to talk to you first and we don't want you running off and doing anything rash."

She began to feel a swell of anger, mixed with sadness and fear.

"Shh, beautiful," Amanda was still saying, over and over. "We're trying to tell you that you helped us."

Sam looked up, surprised, through teary eyes. "I did what?"

Dan smiled at his wife and then Sam. "We've been talking," he said.

Amanda smiled. "I may have acted rashly in telling Dan that I wanted a divorce. I think I was just frustrated and tired of being a prim and proper preacher's wife. I wanted adventure and crazy sex, you know?"

Sam shook her head. "I'm a virgin."

Amanda snickered and brushed her hair some more. "I know angel, but you can understand getting bored and wanting a change, right?"

Sam nodded.

Dan came and sat by his wife, stroking still stroking Sam's face. "Now, I'm going to explain, but you have to listen to what I'm saying. It's important."

She nodded, still confused.

"Somewhere in the middle of this, Amanda figured out what was going on," he explained.

Amanda nodded. "I went and confronted him. I said, "She's only 18, she's just a kid and you're taking advantage of her, how could you!" and over and over," she said.

"She was furious until a couple of days later when I explained our relationship," he said. "She understands now that it wasn't really a sexual thing between you and me. That you were helping me through a dark time."

Sam nodded, hope shining in her eyes for the first time. She sniffled.

"You're such a caring young woman that you helped my husband in a time that most people wouldn't have wanted to get involved in," she said. "You taking the stress away from him, let him relax and come and talk to me. We were able to have a real discussion about our marriage and what was wrong with it."

Sam smiled then. "I did?"

Dan nodded. "I admitted that I really enjoyed your help and that you really seemed to enjoy it."

"That's when I told him that we needed to talk to you and let you know what you'd helped us accomplish," Amanda said, brushing another hair.

"You're not angry with me?" she asked.

"No, angel," Amanda said. "Sweet girl."

"I still don't understand why," Sam said, gesturing to the odd thing she was chained to.

"You see..." Dan started.

"Dan, why don't you leave us girls alone for a minute," Amanda said, smiling and leaning over to kiss him.

He sighed, but nodded and stood, walking to his office and shutting the door behind him.

"Sweetie," Amanda said. "Men... even men as good as the Pastor, always want sex. It's in their blood. Sometimes they want it so much that wives and girlfriends can't keep up. That being said, it's also okay to have different tastes and like different things."

Sam nodded.

"I've always thought you were so beautiful," Amanda admitted, leaning in close. She surprised Sam then with a gentle kiss on the lips. Pulling back, she saw Amanda lick her lips and smile. She cleared her throat and moved around behind Sam.

"You promise that you're not going to run out and get your folks?" she asked.

Sam nodded. "I promise. I'll stay and talk. I want to figure out what's going on."

Amanda began to undo the straps on her legs and allowed to move to a sitting position. She freed her from the wrist cuffs, and as Sam rubbed them, she went and retrieved Sam's shirt.

Turning, they both sat on the couch, Amanda rubbing Sam's shoulders and playing with her long hair.

"You see, by helping my husband relax, you made it possible for us to discuss what we wanted. I actually watched you two one time and I have to admit, I wanted in on the action," Amanda said. She smiled as Sam turned a wide-eyed look towards her.

"You're an incredibly sexy young woman, and you've been so instrumental helping my husband, he and I thought that we might include you more," she said. "We want you to continue helping us in our marriage."

"I did? You do?" Sam asked. She wiped her cheeks and took a tissue from the desk near her to blow her nose. "I'm still confused."

Amanda smiled. "Did you enjoy it when I licked you?" she asked pointedly.

Sam shook her head, but then lowered it and nodded. "I can't lie," she said. "I'm so sorry, but I did."

Amanda snickered. "Honey, I've been wanting to do that for a long time," she said. "I'm bisexual," she said. "It's something that I've thought about doing to you for a while."

Sam's brain did a somersault. "I... but..." she stammered. "You're married to Pastor Dan, though."

Amanda nodded. "He's known for a long time, angel. You'd be surprised to learn some seemingly normal couple's sexual deviances."

Sam couldn't quite comprehend what she was saying.

Dan opened the door, having been listening on the other side. "What she's saying is that because you helped us so much, we want to ask you to keep helping us. You saved our marriage, angel," he said.

Amanda nodded. "Without a doubt."

Smiling widely, Sam looked at both of them. "I did?"

Amanda nodded again. "But... we've still got a long road of healing ahead of us, and we want you to help us in any way you can."

She smiled widely. "Oh, Pastor Dan, Miss Amanda," she said, pulling them both in at the same time for a hug. "I'm happy to help you in any way you need!"

"Samantha," Amanda said. "You need to understand what we're asking, and understand that it's a big step and it's understandable if you don't want to."

Sam sat back, looking at her with big, inquisitive eyes. Amanda reached over and grabbed her purse and pulled out a strap of black lace with a small snap.

"This one is more symbolic," Amanda said. "If you agree, you'll put it on. We'll have a more conventional one for when we're playing together."

Sam, confused, looked at Dan. "It's a collar," he said. "It means that you get to help us repair our marriage some more."

Sam smiled, reaching for it.

"It means," Amanda said, pulling it back just out of reach, "that you will do whatever sexual thing we ask of you."

Sam, looked up at one and then the other, shocked. "But... but what if I can't?" she asked.

"If you put it on, you won't have a choice," Amanda said. "You'll be our little toy to play with; to do with as we please."

Sam started to get worried.

"We're never going to hurt you unless you ask us to," Amanda assured her. "We're never going to make you do anything dangerous or commit any felonies."

Sam nodded.

"What we will do is make you continue to suck my cock," Dan said, smiling.

She couldn't help it and smiled with him.

"But you'll also be asked to do other things as well," Amanda said. "You said you enjoyed what I did to you, right?" she asked.

Sam nodded slowly, finally seeming to understand.

"Look," Dan said, sighing. "I'm sorry to put it into such black and white terms. What we want is for you to be at our sexual beck and call. We want you to spend more time with us, to come home with us, to aid us in the bedroom. We want you to be available to come over at a moment's notice. We can promise that you'll enjoy it the more you commit to it. You'll be asked to do things you think will be a sin. I can promise you that God won't strike you down, and that your soul will never be in danger."

"But should you decide no, that you can't help us, then I really don't know what will happen for Dan and I," Amanda finished. "I know that's a lot to put on one beautiful girl's shoulders, but there it is."

Sam sighed and nodded.

"Take some time and think about it," Amanda said. "Just remember how much you've learned and how much you've enjoyed taking care of my husband."

"And if I decide that I can't be a part of this?" she asked.

"Well, in that case, we'll just be friends," Dan said. "It will make me sad, but we'll keep our boundaries set to a platonic level."

"You've done nothing wrong, angel," Amanda said. "I really hope you decide that you want to keep helping us. I can't wait to show you so much more!"

Sam smiled weakly, very unsure of everything. "I... I need to..." she stopped and sighed. Taking a deep breath, she started again. "I need time to process everything," she said.

Amanda smiled and nodded. "Take my cell number so you can call me and talk to me whenever you have questions," she said.

Sam smiled and reached for her phone. Opening it, she handed it to Amanda who put in her number and handed it back.

"Call me anytime, day or night," Amanda said.

Sam smiled again and stood. "Thank you for..." she started, but then stopped, feeling silly.

"Thank you, angel," Amanda said.

Sam turned and went to the bathroom to clean herself up. A few minutes later, she emerged and said her goodbyes, her mind whirling in confusion.

*****

Alex

The previous Thursday...

Alex awoke a few hours later, still sleeping in the same spot on Dane's chest. Shifting, she looked up and saw him groggily open his eyes. She smiled, inhaling his musk and laid her head back down on his chest.

"Sleep well?" he asked.

She nodded, turning to look at him again. "Like a baby," she said. "You?"

He smiled and pulled the sheet down, revealing the erection he was sporting. She laughed and rolled her eyes. "You're too much," she said. "Put that big son of a bitch away before he gets me."

He laughed and covered himself back up. "Can you blame me? I told you before we went to sleep that you were topless."

She snickered and sat up, turning towards him and stretching, her arms pointing upwards and her back arching. He stared, wide-eyed as her breasts swayed sexily and pointed upwards.

"I thought I was supposed to put this thing away," he said. "You keep doing shit like that, and I might have to throw you down and have my way with you."

She smiled and slid out of bed, still clad only in her panties. "Promises, promises," she replied.

He smirked and slid out bed, pulling his underwear back into place. His erection was still very obvious as he moved to get dressed.

Alex turned and glanced down at it. "That sucker didn't fit, did it," she said, nodding at his cock. Playfully turning and presenting her rump at him again, she wiggled it. "You can always store it in here."

"Goddamnit, Alex," he said, laughing. "If you don't stop, I'm going to shoot Sally across the room."

"You don't wanna shoot me across the room?" she asked playfully, sticking her bottom lip out and pouting at him.

He groaned and threw a pillow at her.

Laughing, she blocked it and went to his door. Peeking out, she looked and didn't see anyone. She walked silently over to her door and saw it open. Danny and Hannah were nowhere to be seen. A devious plan in her mind, she went back to Dane's room.

She crept back in and shut the door. "Dane," she called. "Still wanna see Toni and I together?"

He smiled widely. "What kind of stupid question is that?" he asked.

"I'm pretty sure Danny and Hannah are out. Creep through my closet in a few minutes and you might get a show." Alex winked and turned, heading to her room.

"My dick is just gonna fuckin' explode," he said, shaking his head as she left and causing her to giggle.

Toni was awake fooling around her on phone as Alex entered.

"Morning," Toni said. She didn't speak as she entered, moving up and grabbing onto Toni's panties to pull them off. "I take it our siblings and your roomie are gone?" Toni asked, looking down.

Alex smiled and nodded. "I think Dane might be home."

Toni smirked and allowed Alex to continue, lifting so her twin could pull the underwear completely off. "You guys have been flirting again, haven't you?" she asked.

Alex shrugged. "Maybe," she said, kissing at Toni's ankle and moving slowly upwards.

"And it doesn't bother you that he might come in here?" Toni asked.

She shook her head, her lips and tongue moving upwards to Toni's inner thigh. Alex heard her breathing quicken and looked up into her eyes. Her twin continued to look down at her, love in her eyes.

Slowly and without breaking eye contact, Alex pushed her tongue into Toni's slit and ran it slowly upwards. Toni moaned and relaxed into the pillow, shifting her hips upwards against Alex's mouth.

Slurping and sucking at her twin's pussy, Alex ran a single hand under Toni's thigh and gripped it, causing her to groan. Her tongue, lips, and chin pushing aside Toni's folds, she licked rhythmically at her twin's clit, pausing only to draw the whole fleshy mound into her mouth and pulsate her tongue against it. She could taste how delicious her sister was with every lick and suck, moaning in pleasure every few seconds as she ate.

Alex's other hand was up, mauling her twin's breast and pulling at her nipple. Her flesh was warm and soft under her touch, and Alex wondered then if Dane was watching. If he was, Toni certainly hadn't noticed. She was tightly gripping the covers of the bed, her eyes tightly closed and breathing rapid.

"Fuck... so close," she moaned. "Oh God," she groaned, her breath coming in short gasps. Alex continued to assault her for a few more seconds until she began to cum, climaxing loudly before she covered her face with a pillow. A few more seconds of tongue work, and Alex slid up Toni's body.

Taking a few seconds to catch her breath, Toni pulled Alex up and then lay still, her chest heaving. Alex reached up and played with Toni's hair for a few minutes.

"Yeah, you've definitely been flirting with him this morning," Toni said a few minutes later. "You're so horny it's practically leaking from your eyes."

Alex grinned and nodded, pouting playfully. "Will you lick my pussy for me?"

Toni smiled and began to slide down in the bed, switching places with her. Sliding into place facing the closet, Alex looked in and saw the distinct form of Dane peering out. She waved him in, smiling, but he shook his head.

Toni looked up and raised her eyebrow, turning around and then sighing. "Hi Dane," she said. "I was afraid little Miss Hornball here wouldn't be able to keep her mouth shut."

Alex giggled and lifted her hips to slide her panties off. "I might have been tormenting our brother a little bit and maybe told him that you and I have fucked," she said. "I'm sorry I misbehaved."

Dane still hadn't moved, though he was clearly still watching.

Toni looked back again and waved him in, but he didn't move.

"I guess he's the shy type," Alex said, grinning.

Toni, seeing what she was getting at, smiled back and lowered her face to Alex's pussy.

"Oh God," Alex groaned as Toni's warm tongue slid up her slit. Ribbons of pleasure raced through her body, causing her to arch her back in ecstasy.

There was a loud groan from the closet.

Alex wiggled her finger at Dane to come in again, and lifted Toni's panties from where they lay on the bed. "You should see how big our brother's cock is," Alex said. "It's a little hard to resist for a couple of sluts like us."

He groaned again and Alex had to stop her banter for a moment as Toni renewed her oral assault on her pussy. Her warm lips here pushed tightly up against Alex, sucking gently at her clit.

"Fuck," Alex moaned. "If you want to jerk off, use Toni's panties," Alex said, tossing them into the closet. They weren't very aerodynamic, however, and stopped about halfway. Finally emerging, he came out of the shadows and went to pick up the offered panties.

"There he is," Toni said, looking back. "Gonna dirty up my underwear?" she asked.

He groaned and watched, taking the underwear and sticking them in his boxers.

Alex frowned. "Dane, pull your cock out and let Toni see how big it is," she said. "Please?"

Dane nodded, slipping his underwear off and presenting his impressively erect penis. Underwear in hand, he wrapped them around his shaft and began to stroke.

"This is so fuckin' weird," Toni said, grinning and turning around to slurp at Alex again.