Treasure Beach for Three

I reached for Mala's hips, coaxing her to turn around into a 69 position on top of my wife. It was her turn to pleasure Alice's pussy while I prepared to put myself inside of another woman for the first time in I don't know how many years. Alice's soft moans vibrated against my manhood as Mala bent into position and began lapping at Alice's cunt.

I admired Mala's dripping slit and cute little asshole as she presented herself to me. I decided to leave her waiting in anticipation, so I jerked my cock and enjoyed the feel of my balls sliding against my wife's face. Between the throat trusting and the sloppy ball-play, Alice's makeup was a mess. Her mascara ran down her cheek. She sucked my entire sack into her mouth and moaned approvingly as I positioned my shaft against Mala's wet slit.

I couldn't hold back any longer and was desperate to pump away at the tempting body in front of me. With an eager thrust, I pushed my cock into Mala and was enveloped in her hot flesh. Alice licked my balls with enthusiasm as I thrust into Mala. I enjoyed a handful of Mala's asscheeks and fucked her with complete abandon, shaking the bed violently.

Alice seemed to be enjoying Mala's tongue between her legs and leaned in to return the favor. She tongued Mala's clit, causing her to moan out with approval. Mala was gushing all over my cock and balls. I pumped away at Mala and my balls dragged across Alice's forehead and nose in a mess of spit and vaginal juices while Alice persistently pleasured Mala's clit.

I pulled out my cock and put it in Alice's mouth, giving her a taste of Mala's glaze. I rotated several times between Alice's mouth and Mala's sopping pussy, basking in the responsive feminine purring and soft receptive orifices that craved to be filled with my cock. With Alice perfectly positioned under my balls, I decided to take advantage.

"Mala, why don't you turn back around and lay on top of Alice," I suggested. She turned around with a smile and lowered herself onto Alice, pressing their breasts together. I didn't have to say anything; she knew to take my cock into her throat and did so with relish. Mala and Alice slurped and sucked on my manhood with renewed intensity. My wife's hands eagerly explored Mala's chest as she felt the strands of sticky spit dangling down from Mala's intense throating.

I took Mala by the shoulders, easing her to the side and lowering her onto her back next to my wife. Their upside down heads eyed me with lust as I jerked my cock over their faces.

"Prop your knees up and masturbate for me," I instructed. They eagerly complied and let out some soft moans as I teased their mouths with my cockhead. I held my shaft at the base and rubbed my throbbing member back and forth across their lips and extended tongues. I exploited the pretty faces below me, slapping my cock gently on their foreheads and rubbing it across their noses while they moaned with approval.

"Do you like how I'm taking advantage of you?" I asked.

"Yes, punish us with that big knob of yours," Mala begged.

"You're so fucking big and hard," Alice encouraged. At this point I noticed that they had their hands in each other's laps, rubbing each other intently.

I proceeded to dip my cock into their open mouths. They positioned themselves closer to the edge of the bed, practically hanging off of it so that I could I go deeper into their throats. I was so delirious with pleasure as I humped at their throats with abandon and watched the streams of spit streaking across their foreheads. They turned their faces toward each other and let out a giggle at their messy appearance.

"I'd like to cum inside one of you and have the other lick it up," I suggested, hoping that they would take a final request. "Who wants it?"

"Me! Me!" they begged.

"Cum inside of both of us!" Alice offered, as a solution. Hmmm. I hadn't thought of that.

"Well, it's worth a shot," I replied. Their eyes lit up with excitement at the proposed finale. "Alice, get on top of her and both of you bend your asses toward me."

Mala crouched at the end of the bed and Alice climbed on top, both eagerly stacking their pussies in front of me. I couldn't help but to go in for a taste; I dragged my tongue up the incredibly display of pussy and ass from top to bottom, following with the curves of their cheeks and the sopping slits of their pussies. They cooed and moaned at the strokes of my tongue and begged to have me inside of them. I sucked their engorged pussies into my mouth, one at a time and lapped at their erect clits.

Ready for entry, I held onto Mala's ass and thrust into her, enjoying a second helping of her tight hot pussy. With my cock absolutely soaked in Mala's juices, I pulled out and put myself inside of Alice. She yelped in pleasure as I fucked her nice and hard. Back and forth, I enjoyed as many rounds as I could handle, fucking their dripping cunts and bracing myself for a much needed release.

There was something about the intensity of the situation: the symphony of female moaning, the way they let me have my way with them—my body was producing semen on overdrive and my balls were sucked up tighter than I had ever experienced.

I clenched my toes and groaned loudly as I unloaded the first satisfying spurt deep into Mala's quivering cunt. I pulled out as fast as I could, sending a splatter across their cracks along the way and buried my cock into Alice. I couldn't help but lean in for support against their bodies as I emptied out into Alice's pussy. Alice was trembling and moaning with satisfaction as she felt the last of the gooey deposits spilling out inside of her.

I stood back and watched as they arranged themselves a 69 position with Mala on top. She slurped at Alice's cum-filled pussy and bent her ass over my wife's face. A sticky strand of semen dangled between her pussy lips and Alice accepted it into her mouth with an extended tongue. Alice lifted her head to lick Mala's smooth labia and moaned in pleasure as Mala gave her the same treatment.

They snuggled up, face-to-face, and eagerly explored each other's cum-coated mouths, kissing and giggling naughtily as they observed the stunned look on my face.

"Thank you, Tom!" they said in unison.

"Ah, you're welcome," I mumbled, completely exhausted and overwhelmed by what had just transpired. I honestly couldn't believe it. Was it even happening? Was I really that lucky?

The girls decided to hop into the shower so I slipped downstairs for a beer. I thought It'd be nice to drink it on the beach. I wanted to give them some space, and honestly, I was feeling a little overwhelmed. It was my first sexual experience with two women and my adrenaline was still pumping.

I stood on the moonlit shore and looked out at the sea, sipping on a Red Stripe as the warm tide rushed across my feet. I must have lost track of time because the beach gate opened up and Alice approached from behind, wondering where I had run off to.

"Is everything alright?" she asked with a look of deep concern.

"Yes, absolutely. That was intense. I loved it. I love you," I blurted, feeling a bit emotional as I took her into my arms.

Alice breathed a sigh of relief. "I love you too. I know we agreed not to do presents, but—surprise!" she said with a nervous smile. "Happy anniversary. Happy April Fool's Day."

I furrowed my brow in confusion. "Wait, what?"

As I looked into my wife's eyes my head was spinning, trying to process the unexpected but plainly obvious realization. They were playing me the whole time.

"Mala is my friend from college. Remember, the Indian girl I kissed during a game of spin-the-bottle in college?" she explained. "I'm honestly surprised that you didn't figure it out after how many times I've told you that story."

I smiled and looked down in shame, feeling like a clueless oaf. I can't believe that I didn't see the setup. "Wow, what can I say? I'm speechless."

Alice put a hand on my shoulder, smiling with satisfaction that she could pull off such an elaborate surprise.

"I can't believe Mala would agree to this," I added. "We've never even met."

"Well, it's a kind of long story. We've been planning it for over a year."

I chuckled, still trying to get my head around the details. "Really?"

"Really. I knew that Mala was quite the traveler from all of her online pics, so I asked her about Jamaica, just for suggestions. She was jealous of our trip and joked about coming with. Then, I joked about having a threesome as a anniversary present and that is when it got interesting, " Alice explained.

"Go on," I insisted.

"So, Mala and I were messaging back and forth, dreaming up all sorts of scenarios. We really let the fantasy get carried away. I wanted it so badly. I wanted to show up and see her there waiting for us. I wanted to drag it out for a few days of teasing. I wanted to give you the greatest present ever because you are the greatest husband."

"Wow. I'm sorry if I seem like I'm in shock, I just can't believe you would do this for me. I feel like kind of an asshole now. I didn't get you a present!"

She smiled warmly at me and took me by the hands.

"Oh Tom, don't worry, I'll get my present."

"What do you mean?"

"Well, I have something else to confess."

"Oh yeah?" I asked, dying of curiosity.

"Mala isn't really flying back tomorrow," Alice carefully divulged.

"Really?"

"Really. We just came up with that story just in case we needed to guilt you into doing the anniversary dinner with her. It also made the whole surprise less obvious—letting you think we were just bumping into each other on overlapping trips. She actually got here the same day we did and she's leaving in four days, just like us. We booked the rental together."

"Okay," I replied, quite relieved that she didn't hit me with some other unexpected bombshell. "But what does that have to do with a present?"

"Tom," she said with a gulp and a suggestive smile. "We want you to fuck us for the rest of the trip. That's what Mala and I agreed on. That's our fantasy. That's my present. I want to share your cock with another woman and do everything we've ever fantasized about and maybe even a few things that we haven't."

"What? You're kidding?"

"No I'm not!" she assured me with a laugh. "This isn't just about you. This is my fantasy too and I want more. It's just that I happen to like it when you're in control and Mala likes it too. We want do everything you've ever wanted to do, like watch us eat each other out, cum on our faces, fuck us in the ass, dominate us, whatever you want!"

"Whoa," I said, almost dizzy as I let that last sentence sink in.

"We'll be your submissive little cum-sluts, your fuck dolls that you just play around with however you like. I know that you like to give pleasure too, that's why you make such a great guy for this sort of thing. It's a good plan, right? Can we do it?!"

She gazed at me in hopeful suspense and I just stared back at her, stunned. My cock was practically popping out of my pants as she continued to encourage me.

"What do you say? Can you handle four more days of filthy, naughty threesomes? Who knows, maybe we'll find another girl or two while we're here?"

I cleared my throat. "Um, yeah. I'm in."

"Great! You're the best!" she said with an ecstatic smile and an aggressive hug.

"If you really want this, then I'm happy to do it," I said.

"Yes, I definitely want this. Let's go back up and tell Mala the news!" she begged, pulling on my arm.

As we stepped back into the yard I glanced up at the second floor deck to see Mala's silhouette, looking out over her deck with a drink in hand. I couldn't believe this was going to be the fate of our first trip to Jamaica. I chuckled to myself, thinking about how little we had actually seen of the town since we arrived, given our sexual preoccupations. Alice, the mind reader, chimed in.

"We can go back to sucking and fucking now, but I do expect to see some of the sights while we're here," she said, poking me in the chest playfully.

"Deal," I replied.

Just as we were heading up to rejoin Mala on the second floor, Alice gasped and ran back down to our unit. I waited patiently only to see her return promptly with something in her hand.

"How could I forget this?!" she asked. She held up the bottle of anal lube with a grin. "Just in case."