32

Stories

Stories by Mister_Shy

Married man asks the babysitter to indulge his fetish.

by Mister_Shy
Mature 08/15/2018
H 4.57 183k 243 18 369

She wants her BFF's dad.

by Mister_Shy
Mature 08/28/2017
H 4.58 145.1k 198 19 293

A horny alien impregnates the ship's commander.

by Mister_Shy
NonHuman 05/26/2017
4.39 154.8k 203 13 318
2.94M 4.9k 342 6.5k
1

His sister has a special request.

H 4.68 1.6M 2.6k 116 3.7k
2

Brother and sister get horny in the woods.

H 4.65 548.1k 734 42 967
3

Brother and sister make a pact.

H 4.6 313.3k 495 30 622
4

A new girl complicates Johnny's love life.

H 4.62 230.1k 407 41 509
5

Sister plays hostess at an important dinner.

H 4.78 244.4k 639 113 781
by Mister_Shy
Incest/Taboo& more 06/07/2023
1.5M 1k 106 1.4k
1

Father fights a losing battle of lust for his daughter.

4.28 306.9k 224 8 382
2

Katie wakes her father with a slick surprise.

H 4.54 228.6k 131 10 165
3

Father and daughter finally get it on.

H 4.65 252.1k 157 15 188
4

Daughter surprises father on a business trip.

H 4.66 188.1k 121 13 159
5

Sassy secretary takes matters into her own hands.

H 4.7 104.9k 78 18 102
6

Daughter shares the bed with mom and dad.

H 4.52 188.8k 98 13 139
7

Father roleplays with daughter's roommate.

by Mister_Shy
Anal 08/18/2015
H 4.64 126.1k 122 4 165
8

Father and daughter share an explosive reunion.

H 4.76 105.7k 144 25 192

Student likes to flash her professor.

4.41 80.9k 60 9 92

Mother-in-law is seduced by cuckolded husband.

H 4.66 248.9k 286 65 392
by Mister_Shy
Erotic Couplings& more 11/02/2022
714.2k 628 59 854
1

Girlfriend's sister gives him what he wants.

4.46 275.8k 262 14 394
2

Girlfriend's sister gives him a backstage pass.

by Mister_Shy
Anal 03/13/2011
H 4.59 211.2k 143 9 181
3

Courtney turns the tables.

H 4.64 103.3k 81 7 106
4

Girlfriend's sister meets him at a hotel.

H 4.65 123.8k 142 29 173
by Mister_Shy
Erotic Couplings& more 10/21/2022
320.6k 298 85 432
1

She accepts his indecent proposal.

H 4.53 101.8k 106 14 176
2

She plays into his fantasy.

H 4.62 45.5k 43 11 54
3

They continue their arrangement with saucy photography.

H 4.62 36k 25 7 36
4

After the party she wants him to take her.

by Mister_Shy
Anal 11/08/2011
H 4.58 60k 33 8 46
5

She invites Sara to join them...

by Mister_Shy
Group Sex 03/25/2012
H 4.59 45.3k 28 10 41
6

Catherine and Tom end the affair.

H 4.73 31.8k 63 35 79

Hot young stepmom teaches him yoga.

H 4.62 360.1k 412 40 553

She awakens to a stranger's kiss.

4.44 95.6k 71 19 104
107.3k 132 29 186
1

An invisible man. An open window. A beautiful neighbor.

H 4.62 70.5k 95 7 142
2

Invisible man is mistaken for a demon.

H 4.52 36.8k 37 22 44